The Disappointment We Cannot Prevent
Ten Lessons in Living Well 4
During the recent election, I ended up in an awkward spot between two friends. I respected them both, and each cared a lot about who would win a certain public office. The problem was, they disagreed about who should get the job.
One of my friends was running for the office. I knew him well and appreciated his experience, dedication to public service, and passion for the issues. I thought he would do a good job, so I was glad to support him. Another friend supported a different candidate. She was just as passionate and tried hard to convince me that my candidate wasn’t qualified. We talked about it several times, and she made good points. I listened and thought about what she said, but I wasn’t willing to give up on a good friend with equal qualifications.
There were three candidates, and I thought two of them had the right experience and judgment for the job. My friend’s choice was one of those two. I respected her qualifications and would have supported her if my candidate didn’t advance. I told my friend this, though I think she wished I’d decided sooner.
She kept trying to change my mind, and I could tell my decision disappointed her. I didn’t like that feeling. Her friendship mattered to me, and I knew she cared about the result. Still, I had thought it through, and my reasons for supporting my candidate stayed the same. Eventually, my candidate was eliminated from the race. I was disappointed, both for him and for the chance I thought he offered. But my other friend’s candidate was still in, so I was happy to support her. I had respected her qualifications from the start and wanted someone good for the community in that office.
I was also glad I hadn’t spent the past weeks criticizing her. Politics often tempts people to say things about opponents that are awkward if those people later become allies. I managed to avoid that embarrassment this time, but I can assure my friends know I’m not always perfect at avoiding those arguments.
Looking back, I think this experience taught me something about what we expect from our friends. We all want the people we care about to agree with us, especially when something is important. Their support can feel like loyalty, and their disagreement can feel personal. I’ve felt that too. Sometimes I just couldn’t understand why someone I respected didn’t see what seemed obvious to me. Of course, the other person was probably thinking the same thing about me.
The Stoics knew that relationships get complicated when we let our happiness depend too much on others’ approval. Epictetus starts the Enchiridion by pointing out the difference between what we can control and what we can’t. Our judgments, choices, and actions are up to us. Other people’s opinions and decisions are not.
That idea is easy to accept when it’s about strangers. It’s much harder when we want approval from someone we love or respect. I could listen to my friend, take her arguments seriously, and think about my position. I could explain my reasons without criticizing her candidate or doubting her motives. Those were my choices. But whether she was satisfied with my decision was up to her, not me.
There’s a difference between caring about someone’s feelings and thinking we have to keep them from being disappointed. I’ve probably mixed up those two more often than I’d like to admit. That difference matters because disappointment is a normal part of relationships. We build hopes for people around us, sometimes without noticing how many expectations we have. We think they’ll agree with us, make certain choices, or act like we would. When they don’t, we’re left wondering why.
Sometimes disappointment shows we’ve really failed. Maybe we broke a promise, treated someone unfairly, or ignored a responsibility. Those times deserve our attention, and we should admit the harm we’ve caused. Other times, someone is disappointed just because we made a choice they wouldn’t have made.
I think wisdom means looking closely at that difference. We can ask if our decision was thoughtful, if we acted with integrity, and if we treated the other person with respect. If we find we acted badly, we can try to make it right. If our conscience is clear, we may just have to accept that someone we care about wishes we’d chosen differently.
The Stoic virtue of justice also has a place here. Justice asks us to consider the people affected by our actions and to treat them fairly. For me, that meant seeing both candidates’ strengths and respecting my friend’s right to her own view. I owed her an honest talk, and I wanted to keep our friendship through our disagreement. I hope that’s how it worked out. We’re still friends, and I think we understand each other well enough to accept some differences. I was glad to support her candidate when things changed, and I hope she knew my earlier disagreement wasn’t about her judgment or our friendship.
There’s a helpful habit here that could make life a bit easier. Next time someone seems disappointed by our choice, we can pause and think about what happened. Did we break a promise or treat someone unfairly? Or did we just make a decision that was ours to make, even if someone else wanted a different result?
It’s good to ask ourselves this before guilt makes us apologize for something that doesn’t need an apology. We can recognize someone’s feelings, listen to their concerns, and stay open to changing our minds. We can also let a disagreement stay unresolved without letting it hurt the respect or affection we feel. I’m still learning how to do this. I like agreement as much as anyone, and I really appreciate it when people I care about support my choices. But friendship would be exhausting if every disagreement meant one of us had to give up our own judgment.
That election reminded me that people can share values but still make different choices about how to live them out. We might disappoint each other sometimes. I’m sure it will happen again. I hope that when it happens, we’ll remember that friendship matters more than any one disagreement, and that sometimes the kindest thing we can do is give each other the freedom to decide for ourselves.
